Drugs aren’t bad, mmmmkay?

stern man asking r u on drugs?
You are. You're just in denial.

The past week or so the media has been afire with moral panic about the drug mephedrone (aka mcat, miaow miaow etc). As I type it’s a legal substance, being sold in slightly dodgy circumstances to young folk – and not so young folk – looking for a bit of fun.

Some of those people have died, although there are conflicting reports about this. Some deaths attributed to mephedrone have been found to be due to other causes. I want to make it clear from the outset that those deaths are tragic, no question about it.

But the moral panic that has ensued is what’s pissing me off. And it’s my rant for today.

Now, this rant could go a few ways: I could rant about pandering politicians with their eyes on the election, or the farce that is the official drugs advisory body, or the media (but Charlie Brooker did that so much better than I ever could). No, today’s topic is the moral panic itself.

Here’s my thesis: in modern, Western society taking drugs is a normal part of life. More: it is such an entrenched part of our social order that not taking drugs requires effort. To arbitrarily call one chemical ‘good’ and one ‘bad’ is irrational, hypocritical and wasteful. Drugs, and all other chemicals, are neither good nor bad: they have both desirable and undesirable effects. They have a place in our society – including for consenting adult pleasure – and we need a rational way of managing our approach to new chemicals to ensure we can benefit from their good properties and minimise the harm from the bad.

Test my theory. Try to go a week without: alcohol, aspirin, caffeine, ibuprofen, nicotine, paracetamol, ventolin. Give up your morning joe, your soft drink, your energy shot, your sneaky half on the way home, your glass of wine over dinner. It’s hard work. And why would we want to deny ourselves those things?

So why get so upset about mephedrone? My suspicion is that the panic is to do with the fact that people are taking it for leisure and pleasure. We have a puritanical, reactionary fear of people enjoying themselves too much. What do we have against the idea of adults choosing to spend their leisure time having some chemically enhanced fun? The usual argument is that these substances are harmful to individuals and society but analysis of the facts suggests we have one rule for some substances and one for others.

Alcohol was directly linked to the deaths of over 9000 people in the UK in 2008. That’s pretty close to 25 people a day. And the statistical definition of alcohol death does not include suicide, accidental death or sudden death. So if someone was killed by a drunk driver, they don’t get counted as a death caused by alcohol, although most of us would agree that it was clearly a cause, if not the sole cause.

So: on one hand we have a substance that is, according to reports, the fourth most popular party drug-de-jour that (benefit of the doubt) has killed at most 25 people[1] in the UK since it hit the scene in summer 2009. On the other hand, we have a substance that kills at least 25 people a day. Guess which one they want to ban?

There’s another substance that 90% of adults in the US (Wikipedia) consume daily. It is lethal, although in practice deaths are rare because the dose taken is so small. In moderate doses (well below lethal) it significantly increases the risk of miscarriage but we put it in sweets and soft drinks. It has been linked to psychiatric disorders. Caffeine, of course.

Here’s how it compares to the evil mephedrone[2]:

Caffeine Mephedrone
Effect Psychoactive stimulant Stimulant
Desirable effects Alertness
Reduced fatigue
Increased focus
Better general body coordination
Vivid perception
Desire to talk
Undesirable effects Anxiety
Cold sweats
Nausea and vomiting
Increased heart rate
Increased sensitivity to touch
Increased sweating
Nausea and vomiting
Abnormal heart rate
Circulation problems

So why is one drug considered evil and one considered so safe that we put it in every day food items?

It’s not about dosage: 2 grams of caffeine is sufficient to cause hospitalisation. Nobody is even discussing whether mephedrone could be safe in smaller doses, whether different methods of consumption would make it safe. Hell no, it must be banned!

We persistently promote a myth that the only people who take drugs are somehow deficient: that they are depressed or from fucked up backgrounds or have no moral standards. But, going back to my point at the beginning, it’s just not true. We all take drugs, daily. We take them because they work. And even amongst the sub-group that will take illegal drugs the same rule applies. A raver who takes ecstasy every weekend does it because it feels so good that the ensuing mid-week depression is worth it, just as the middle-aged middle manager who goes out on Friday night and gets blattered on lager does it because taking the kids to football practice on Saturday with a hangover is worth it (and s/he can take another few drugs to minimise the symptoms….)

This hypocritical, irrational approach to drugs does not serve us as a society. We waste extensive resources on policing and monitoring our collective fears, resources that could be used for good. Think how much time is being wasted by bureaucrats and politicians trying to scrabble to ban mephedrone: and what a lovely distraction from coming up with real policies for the election!  Mephedrone may not have any beneficial uses to society other than pleasure, and in the final assessment may be too toxic and addictive to be desirable, but maybe in a different form – perhaps as a liquid alternative to alcohol – perhaps the harm could be reduced and it could have a legitimate place in our chemically-altered world. And instead of this ridiculous panic, we could have an adult conversation about the appropriate place for recreational substances.

That’s my two cents.

[1] At the time of writing, various unconfirmed sources are citing numbers of between 2 and 25 people having died in the UK from taking mephedrone. For the sake of argument, I have taken the highest figure.

[2] I will confess to being selective in my choices here to make a point. But it’s all factual as far as I can manage – there’s not as much scientific information about mephedrone as caffeine though.

Postscript 15 July 2010

Further reading from the British Medical Journal, a proposal for a rational regulation of drugs, “An alternative to the war on drugs”

4 thoughts on “Drugs aren’t bad, mmmmkay?

  1. I think you’re wrong Jana…. not everyone takes drugs daily. There’s ‘taking drugs’ and there’s ‘taking drugs’. Or rather, there is taking drugs and using drugs. You’re confusing the two.

    Taking drugs. I think too many people take too many drugs for too many wrong reasons. I’m talking about medication – pain killers, antib’s, drugs for hypertension, anti depressants, mood stabilizers etc etc ad infinitum. Our society is plagued with the notion that adding chemicals to the body and mind will correct their problems. It’s a big subject but to keep it simple – for the most part, the problem is in the mind and therefore the solution is in the mind. Granted there is a place for some medications but most people think that relying on outside sources by adding something will fix their health issues and they’re wrong. The more you medicate, the more you’ll medicate…. What is needed is restoration of balance. More exercise, more walking, more deep breathing, more early to bed early to rise, more decent food and more relaxation….(and not chemically induced or enhanced either)

    And about using drugs…. caffeine, ciggers, weed, alcohol etc etc is crap for your body and crap in your mind. I’ve never used other drugs so can’t say what they did for me, but it’s on the cards that they’re more of the same. People use drugs because they feel they are not enough and they want more. This comes from our society’s emphasis on consumerism. Happiness is not in getting what you want (because there’s no end to the wanting) it is in the mind. Happiness is a skill that you hone. It’s an attitude, it’s a state of mind that is natural to the mind if you give yourself half a chance to experience it. Using drugs makes the mind dull and it makes people mediocre and weak.

    I guess in the last few years I have come to understand and experience what a finely tuned instrument the human body is. And how it will function beautifully if we leave it alone and let it breathe freely and unfettered with chemicals and additives…..

    I’ve never really put my thoughts about these things down in this kind of format (poetry has been my forte) so my choice of words don’t really express what I’m wanting to say in the way I really want to say it (wooden writing I call it, but I’ll improve….) But basically, that’s my opinion.

    I like that you write about controversial things. I find that my opinions these days are pretty different to most people around me including those who consider themselves to be intellectuals, and that surprises me. But I’m open and want to learn how to say what I think so that people know what I mean…..


    1. I think there’s probably something in what you’re saying about letting the body be free of all chemicals but I don’t really know anything about that subject. As a society we seem to believe that using chemicals in our body is OK, so in this essay I take that POV for granted. From there, my point is that drugs – legal and illegal – are just chemicals and it’s irrational for social policy to be based on anything but the toxicity of the chemicals. Here in the UK, the Daily Mail (over-the-top conservative tabloid paper with very low standards of journalism) seems to have more sway over government drugs policy than scientists.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s